Advertising: Created Dissatisfaction

nyc-923412-300x199 Advertising: Created Dissatisfaction

“Advertisement constantly proposes to the consumer that which he does not have and which is just beyond his reach.”

Everyone imagines that advertising has as its goal the satisfaction of the consumer’s desire. A person supposedly obtains happiness by buying the product.

RTO-mini2 Advertising: Created DissatisfactionFree Book: Return to Order: From a Frenzied Economy to an Organic Christian Society—Where We’ve Been, How We Got Here, and Where We Need to Go

However, the logic of such a supposition actually leads to the opposite conclusion: advertising does not create satisfaction but dissatisfaction. It constantly proposes to the consumer that which he does not have and which is just beyond his reach. He is promised status if he buys a product that is above his current economic level and tends to be uneasy until he reaches his new status.

What makes people happy is not upward comparisons but downward comparisons. A person experiences a certain happiness knowing he has advanced economically and not when he is challenged to buy a more expensive product. Advertising is successful to the degree it increases uneasiness with one’s present status.


Robert E. Lane notes that, “Although it is said that the function of the market is to satisfy human wants and so to maximize various satisfactions, it is not true that the function of advertising is to maximize satisfaction; rather, its function is to increase people’s dissatisfaction with any current state of affairs, to create wants, and to exploit the dissatisfactions of the present. Advertising must use dissatisfaction to achieve its purpose. (Robert E. Lane, The Loss of Happiness in Market Democracies, New Haven, Yale University Press, 2000, p. 179.)

What Does Saint Thomas Say About Marriage?

  • Frances O’Dair

    I agree about the negative effects of advertising. At one time the saying was, “Necessity is the Mother of Invention”. Today technological innovation continues to necessitate the purchase of the newest and the better product. Rather than achieving our basic needs, new products come into the marker which compel the consumer to buy it. It is difficult to distinguish between what one actually needs and what one thinks they need for the good life. We are satisfied with the new for a short time, but tend to anticipate what will be available in the future. Obviously things don’t satisfy the human spirit. Until a person takes the time to count one’s blessings, they will never be satisfied.

  • Thomas L. Stafford

    It is not that dire. Yes, there is some of that, But, the grounded individual is not effected much by it.