Not Everyone’s Doing It

contradicton-of-lifestyles Not Everyone’s Doing ItOne of the perceptions that fuel frantic lifestyles is the idea that everyone is involved in a particular fad or fashion. Especially in our mass society, the penalty for not being part of what “everyone is dong” is to risk being labeled out of sync with the times. No where is this perception more common than in the fast moving world of the Internet

Conventional wisdom claims everyone is online and no one can survive without a connection. The drive to digital lifestyles is seemingly unstoppable and inevitable.

RTO-mini2 Not Everyone’s Doing ItFree Book: Return to Order: From a Frenzied Economy to an Organic Christian Society Where Weve Been, How We Got Here, and Where We Need to Go


However, the facts do not support this conclusion. A surprisingly large and stable sector of Americans is quite content to be offline. A recent Pew Research survey found that some 15 percent of Americans do not use the Internet on any device and another nine percent use it only at their workplaces. A surprising 92 percent of these offline adults are quite content to remain unconnected.

“Most offline adults either don’t see the Internet as relevant to them, or feel that it would not be worth the effort,” said Kathryn Zickuhr, a Pew researcher and author of the report on the poll. “And though many have had some experiences with the Internet in the past, most non-Internet users say they are not interested in going online in the future.”

This rejection of the online world is not limited to older people. While older people are more likely to be offline, the youngest polled adults (age 18-29) listed 13 percent of the group without an online connection. Some of the nonuser even live together with others who are connected while others were seasoned Internet users before giving it up.

The poll does not support the conclusion that use of the Internet is necessarily harmful. People can and often must use it for all sorts of reasons. However, the poll does say that there is life beyond the Internet. People can and do exercise the option of staying offline. The frantic perception of “everyone is doing it” that fuels an economy of frenetic intemperance can be opposed by simply pulling the plug.

What Does Saint Thomas Say About Immigration?

2 thoughts on “Not Everyone’s Doing It

  1. I do have an Internet connection at home, but about the only thing I use it for is as a study aid and for free reading material. The rest of it isn’t worth the trouble, or is too time-consuming. I have better things to do with my time.

  2. I’m not following the logic of this post. Is this post contending that mere use of the Internet is necessarily harmful? Or is that charge limited to use in one’s spare time (i.e., outside of professional or academic requirements)?

    That those considered “unconnected” by the survey are content to do so does not tell us that they lead especially fulfilling or virtuous lives. Indeed, if they’re all living in a socialist commune together, we would not consider them laudatory at all. We merely know that they do not have an especial interest in the use of something that has become as commonplace as most public utilities (and there are plenty of handfuls of people who opt out of those as well). Their numbers include Mormons, Anarchists, Amish, Orthodox Jews, Hippies, Fundamentalist Protestants, Communists, Survivalists, and traditional Catholics, among others. Groups representing a broad strata of philosophical dispositions, to be sure.

    The post’s central contention seems to be with use of the Internet itself, and that it is at best a necessary evil in some contexts. But if it is a necessary evil, the post begs the question as to why and how it is an evil. The post seems to assume it is self-evident when it is not.

    Could you please clarify, Mr. Horvat?

    May I submit that my motivation for this query is that fact that many millennial traditionalists like myself would have no contact with TFP and other meritorious institutions were it not for this undeservedly maligned connectedness? That contact comes outside of professional and academic obligations as well.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *