From the Mail: Can the State Be “Perfect?”

From the Mail: Can the State Be “Perfect?”

“today one could say that the modern bureaucratic State is ‘imperfect’ in the popular sense of the word meaning ‘flawed’ or ‘full of defects.'”

I received an email from a friend that questioned my formulation that the State is a perfect society and that families depend upon the State. He contended that the opposite is true: the State needs families and the adjective “perfect” can never be used when referring to the State.

Of course, the State does need the family. The family is the basic social unit of society. It is the building block from which the edifice of society is built. Without the building block of the family, there can be no State.

RTO mini2Free Book: Return to Order: From a Frenzied Economy to an Organic Christian Society—Where We’ve Been, How We Got Here, and Where We Need to Go

But a building block is just that: a block from which to build something. Families build society. Families build economies. Families build cultures. Families build States. However, a block all by itself cannot fulfill its constructive function. It needs social relationships and governing structures to allow it to be a “building” block and not an isolated piece of construction material.

It is true, as my correspondent later affirmed, there were historical circumstances when the family survived in a very isolated state with seemingly little need of higher structures. Families living on the frontier, for example, were very self-sufficient. However, even these families interacted with other families. Families needed other families to produce new families lest their genetic stock became too close. They gathered together in small settlements. Primitive governing structures always arose naturally to take care of problems of the common good, lest bandits or outlaws took control.

This happened because the State is a spontaneous and natural organism that springs up from the inherent needs of man’s social nature. It is not an artificial construct or a necessary evil but rather a social good. Its role must, of course, be very limited to the basic ordering and protection of the common good. It should then allow families, associations, parishes, and other groups to operate freely and amply. This is what constitutes the rich social life of a nation.

When this happens, the organic State is “perfect” in the sociological sense that it is complete. It is not the building block of anything else but contains all the means in itself to fulfill its limited functions in regard to the basic social units that compose it.

However, today one could say that the modern bureaucratic State is “imperfect” in the popular sense of the word meaning “flawed” or “full of defects.” In its present bloated condition, the modern State seems to destroy the very institutions it should defend. It absorbs the family and all intermediary institutions and takes over their functions. It suffocates a rich social life that allows men to prosper.

This highlights the need to return to an organic order in which that sociologically perfectFree Subscription to our Weekly e-Newsletter State will be reduced to its limited role. There is a need to return to that rich social life that is the natural line of defense against the abuses of government. The family needs to become once again that ideal and essential building block.

Until then, as my correspondent noted, we are doomed to suffer the constant disorder of an “imperfect” State where the family must resist its many encroachments.


 Related Articles: We Must Resist the Temptation to Secession




  • pearl87

    It seems your statement that the “state is perfect” SHOULD be the “perfect state is perfect” which is simply redundant. However, unless we are in paradise, your original statement is always false. No human state will ever be perfect in any sense of that word, until Our Lord perfects it.

    • Danny

      He is not talking about the family and society in a religious sense. The family is imperfect because it needs doctors, teachers, firemen, etc, to help it. The state is perfect because it has all the means to fulfill it end. The only perfect spiritual society is the Catholic Church because it has all the means to fulfill its end. The Church’s means are the sacraments, prayer, etc. Its end is the salvation of souls.