A Lesson In Innocence

Lesson_in_innocence-3 A Lesson In Innocence

One September morning in the year 1897, the editor of a New York daily newspaper called The Sun found a letter from an eight-year-old girl on his desk. The letter read:

Dear Editor:

I am eight-years-old. Some of my friends always tell me that Father Christmas does not exist. However, my father says that if The Sun says Father Christmas exists then he really does exist. Please tell me the truth: does Father Christmas really exist?


Virginia O’Hanlon

RTO-mini2 A Lesson In InnocenceFree Book: Return to Order: From a Frenzied Economy to an Organic Christian Society—Where We’ve Been, How We Got Here, and Where We Need to Go


Francis Church, the editor of The Sun, reluctantly and with much hesitation took upon himself the task of answering little Virginia’s letter. However, once he had begun, the words came readily to mind. Here is his letter:


“Virginia, your friends are wrong. They have a terrible disease which later on will bring them even greater pain. Be careful not to catch this disease. This is a disease of the soul. We adults called it incredulity, cynicism, lack of innocence. Your friends and the other people who tried to persuade you think they are wise and smart because they only admit as real that which they can see with their eyes and touch with their hands. But, they do not realise how much they are limiting themselves!


Little Virginia, imagine the whole of this immense globe with its lakes and mountains, with its rivers and seas, and, hovering over our heads, the infinite heavens with its thousands of stars. Imagine how many species of animals exist in the sea, in the air and on the land. Man is only one among thousands of beings, and how small we are! In face of the immense universe, man is but a fly or an ant. How then can man see everything that exists or with his limited understanding try to explain everything?


Yes, Virginia, Father Christmas exists! He exists just as much as tenderness and joy exist, or as love and goodness exist, even though we cannot see these things with our eyes and touch them with our hands. You yourself have felt these things. And don’t they bring beauty and joy into your life?


Oh, how sad the world would be without Father Christmas! It would be as sad as a world without Virginias, without fairy tales, the angels, songs, children’s stories written by the poets. Or, on the contrary, imagine a world where no one ever became enchanted with anything or never smiled! We then would all be lost. And that eternal light, that never extinguishes, with which children light up the world and accompanies every child that is born, would be extinguished forever.


Lesson_in_innocence A Lesson In InnocenceNot to believe in Father Christmas?! Then no one would need to believe in fairies and angels. You could convince your father to put watchmen by every chimney on Christmas Eve so he could grab Father Christmas. What would be proven if they did not see him coming down the chimney? Nobody sees Father Christmas! But this does not prove that he does not exist. The things in this world that are really for real neither children nor adults can see. Have you ever seen a fairy dance in the flowery meadows? Just because you have not seen them does not prove that they don’t dance in the flowery meadow. No one can understand all the invisible marvels of the universe.


You can disassemble a rattle in order to see how the sound of the little stones is produced. But there is a veil hiding the invisible world that nobody, not even the strongest man or the strength of the whole world, can push aside. Only faith and charity can raise this veil a little bit and thus be able to contemplate the beauty and splendour hidden behind.

What Does Saint Thomas Say About Immigration?


Is this reality? Oh, Virginia, on earth there is nothing more real or truer than this! Thanks be to God, Father Christmas lives and will live forever! For the next thousand years—oh! little Virginia—for the next ten thousand years multiplied by a thousand years, Father Christmas will continue to live in the pure hearts of children that are filled with joy and that beat with increased excitement on Christmas Day!”



  • gestr

    I never told my children that Santa or fairies were real. It’s not necessary to lie to the innocent to captivate their souls with the reality of Our Savior. I don’t think the early Christians resorted to foisting make-believe on their children in order to give them a little fake joy. In fact, lying to children about Santa’s existence may be at the root of our present day apostasy among the young: they refuse to believe in God, saying it’s “fairy tales.”

    • Jameson

      Well, if you told your children that Saint Nicholas did not exist then you lied to your children.

    • charleslarue

      he is talking about the spirit of Christmas. If there ever is a time of year to begin forgiving, especially in families, it’s advent; and if there is a time for joy, it’s Christmas. What do children know of forgiving and joy? They can know it better by stories, so we have Saint Nicholas, a bishop who lived in the fourth century in what is now Turkey. Tell them his story as well.

  • Gloria Gloria

    i thought that father Christmas existed until I discover his identity… what is wrong with that? I used to enjoy so much Christmas the tree the presents and Father Christmas believed. It is a time to love and to think in Christ’s birth, the grotto the animals the little docs on the mirror making it look like a lake…. What is wrong with all that? Father Christmas existed also as a person.. Saint Nicolas… and he is making sure that Christian children are happy in his name!

  • Michael Robinson

    Why did you re-write the article so that the words used are completely different from the original?

    • disqus_eXiTt9z5RX

      Don’t know if this is true, but if so, why do you care? Authors often review past works and improve as desired.

  • I told The Nephews the legend about Bishop Nicholas and how it got to be traditional for people to play at “being Santa Claus” in different ways each year. Of course there are lots of different Santa Clauses, and when old enough to recognize them in the silly hats, you can be one too.

    What I wish my elders had told me, and now tell children: Whenever clothes are too small or books or toys seem too childish, you get the pleasure of giving prezzies to younger children. Instead of debunking Santa, be one.